Has Your Family Been Kicked Out of the Library?


by Patt Ligman


"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

—The First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution

"Books and ideas are the most effective weapons against intolerance and ignorance."

—Former U.S. President Lyndon Baines Johnson



What Can You Do to Stop Books from Being Banned?
Here are some suggestions for you to do (be sure to check with your parent[s] first!):

1. If your library has books like those named in this article, write a letter to your community's library board and thank them! You might also want to tell them how important it is for you to read and show your friends books about families with LGBT parents just like yours.

2. If your library doesn't have these books, write a letter to your community's library board and ask that they buy them. You could also write a similar letter to the public library's head librarian. Be respectful, but tell them how much it means to you to be able to read books representing your family.


Please send Rainbow Rumpus a copy of what you write. Email it to editor@rainbowrumpus.org We will publish some of your letters next month! Whatever you do, be respectful of the rights of others who disagree with you because the First Amendment really is for everyone!



"I think the most un-American thing you can say is, 'You can't say that.'"

—Garrison Keillor, author and the creator of National Public Radio's "Prairie Home Companion"

 

FEATURED BOOKS FROM TWO LIVES PUBLISHING (www.twolives.com)

Mom and Mum Are Getting Married! by Ken Setterington (ages 4–8): Rosie’s two mothers are getting married, and she wonders if she will get to be the flower girl.

And Tango Makes Three by Justin Richardson and Peter Parnell (ages 4 and up): The story of two famous dads, who happen to be penguins in New York’s Central Park Zoo.

When Grownups Fall in Love by Barbara Lynn Edmonds (ages 3–6): Told in rhyme, this book explains how grownups fall in love.

Flying Free by Jennifer C. Gregg (ages 3–6): Violet, a five-year-old girl with two moms, captures a firefly, who tries several times to free himself from the jar he is trapped in.

Going to Fair Day by Brenna and Vicki Harding (ages 5–7): This book from Australia features a girl going to the fair with her two moms.

Zack’s Family by Keith Elliot Greenberg (ages 7–10): Told from the viewpoint of Zack, it’s the story of his living with two moms while still visiting his father.

King & King by Linda de Haan (ages 3–6): It’s time for the prince to marry, but he is unable to fall in love with any of the princesses and instead falls in love with another prince—and they live happily ever after.

Love Makes a Family by Gigi Kaeser and Peggy Gillespie (photographs and essays): An award-winning book featuring first-person essays and black-and-white photographs telling the stories of LGBT families.

 

You might be suprised by the answer! Some people want to take away the right to read books about families like yours and mine: families with two moms or two dads, families with a single LGBT parent, families with LGBT relatives. These people want to stop everyone from reading books like King & King and Mom and Mum Are Getting Married! They want to keep these books from being put in public libraries, and they want to force librarians and school boards to take them out of libraries.

What they want to do is ban books, even books written by famous authors. Some of these book banners even publicly burn books they don't like.

They want to ban books even though our freedom to read any book is guaranteed by the First Amendment. The First Amendment is part of the United States Constitution. A constitution is a written document containing the basic laws that help guide the government of a country. The constitution shows what people in the country believe is important.

When thirty-nine men signed the U.S. Constitution in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, on September 17, 1787, not everyone was happy. The Constitution described how the U.S. government would work. It did not guarantee Americans basic freedoms, like the freedom to say what they wanted.

Four years later, Americans got that guarantee when the Bill of Rights was ratified on December 15, 1791.

Ten original amendments formed the Bill of Rights in 1791; today there are twenty-seven amendments. But few people would disagree that the First Amendment (see above) deserves its place at the top of the list. Among other rights, the First Amendment guarantees Americans the right to say—and write—almost anything. We are free to criticize our government, write make-believe stories, and tell others about our lives and our families.

If someone wants to ban a book from a school or library, they challenge it. Before a book can be removed from a library or school, several other steps must be taken. Some of the most-often challenged books are those written about families with two moms or two dads, families with other LGBT relatives, and books about LGBT people. Some challenged books that have kids with LGBT parents are:

King & King and King & King & Family by Linda de Haan and Stern Nijland

The Family Book written and illustrated by Todd Parr

The Trouble with Babies by Martha Freeman

Jack by A. M. Holmes

Heather Has Two Mommies by Lesléa Newman

Daddy's Roommate by Michael Willhoite

You can learn a little more about these books and others like them at the bottom of this page.

You can make sure everyone can read about families like yours by responding to the suggestions on the right side of the page.

A Short Selection of Books Featuring LGBT Families

Below are just a few of the books available to young readers in which LGBT families and/or relatives are mentioned or featured. This is not a complete list; there are many, many more books out there for you to read and explore!

Remember that many of these books have been challenged in libraries all over the United States. Look to see if they’re in your library!

BOARD BOOKS FOR THE VERY YOUNG
Too Far Away to Touch by Lesléa Newman (ages 5–8): Zoe’s uncle has AIDS, and he explains to her that after he dies he will be like the stars: close enough to see and too far away to touch.

The White Swan Express by Jean Davies Okimoto and Elaine M. Aoki (ages 5–8): Four couples adopt children from China and are getting ready for the Big Day when the children arrive home; one family is a lesbian family.

The Family Book written and illustrated by Todd Parr (ages 3–6): A variety of families are mentioned, including families with two moms and two dads.

My Really Cool Baby Book written and illustrated by Todd Parr (for parents): A baby book designed with busy parents and diverse families in mind for the first year of baby’s life.

Tiger Flowers by Patricia Quinlan (ages 5–8): When Joel’s uncle dies of AIDS, Joel’s dreams and thoughts help keep his uncle’s memory alive.

One Dad, Two Dads, Brown Dad, Blue Dads by Johnny Valentine (ages 3–6): A child with two blue dads and one with a traditional family compare notes and wonder why blue dads are different.

My Two Uncles by Judith Vigna (ages K-grade 2): Elly’s grandparents are celebrating their fiftieth wedding anniversary, but trouble erupts because her grandfather doesn’t approve of Elly’s uncle being gay.

Anna Day and the O-Ring written and illustrated by Elaine Wickens (preschool – grade 1): Evan and his two moms try to put up the tent he receives for his birthday, but the o-ring needed to finish the job is missing.

CHAPTER BOOKS AGES 5–12
Molly’s Family by Nancy Garden (ages 4–8): When Molly draws a picture of her family as part of a classroom assignment, she is jeered because she draws her two moms.

Living in Secret by Christina Salat (ages 9–12): Eleven-year-old Amelia runs away from her father, who has custody of her, to be with her mother and her mother’s girlfriend.

Holly’s Secret by Nancy Garden (ages 4-8): When Holly’s family moves to the country from New York City, she hatches a plan to hide the fact she has two lesbian moms.

INTERMEDIATE & YOUNG ADULT BOOKS
Jack by A. M. Homes. (young adult): Fifteen-year-old Jack is confused about his feelings for his father, who divorced Jack’s mother four years ago; Jack finds out his dad is gay.

Am I Blue? Coming Out from the Silence edited by Marion Dane Bauer, a member of Rainbow Rumpus’s Author Advisory Board (young adult): A collection of short stories written by several well-known children’s and young adult authors that are all about LGBT identities.

Who Framed Lorenzo Garcia? by R. J. Hamilton (ages 12 and up): Ramon is a gay fifteen-year-old who is ready to start a new phase of his life with Lorenzo Garcia, a cop who wants to adopt Ramon.

The Arizona Kid by Ron Koertge (young adult): Sixteen-year-old Billy spends the summer in Arizona with his cool gay uncle; he works at a horse racetrack and falls in love with a feisty exercise girl.

Earthshine by Theresa Nelson (young adult): Slim watches over her father during his struggle with AIDS with the help of her father’s partner.

From the Notebooks of Melanin Sun by Jacqueline Woodson, a member of Rainbow Rumpus’s Author Advisory Board (age 12 and up): Fourteen-year-old Melanin Sun, an African American boy growing up with his single mother in Brooklyn, enjoys his quiet, carefree life—until his mother tells him she is in love with another woman.


RAINBOW RUMPUS - The MAGAZINE for KIDS with LGBT parents
PO Box 6881, Minneapolis, MN 55406
- editor@rainbowrumpus.org

Bulletin Board // Stories and Poems // Reviews // Music and Video // Political // For Parents